Comments on: The unwritten revelations of Sarath Fonseka’s letter requesting retirement from service https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service Journalism for Citizens Mon, 23 Nov 2009 12:14:52 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.4.1 By: Indi https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-11149 Mon, 23 Nov 2009 12:14:52 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-11149 Why has it become a problem to some that General Fonseka might stand for Presidency. Any man or woman belonging to any ethnic nationality, Sinhalese, Tamil,Muslim or Burgher should have the freedom and the right to stand for Presidency or for parliament, if Sri Lanka is a true democracy.
Sri Lankans are known to be a very intelligent and a clever group of people world over. Let us place our trust on the intergrity of freedom loving Sri Lankans to elect whom they think is worthy of uniting and taking Sri Lanka forward to a new era, free from corruption, evil and thuggery for which Sri Lanka is now fast gaining a reputation world wide.
What S/L needs is diciplined politicians who have the guts and the courage to bring law and order to a very corrupt nation. Both MR and SF are people who have won the hearts of many Sri Lankans. While SF has played a significant role in defeating terrorism, by training and leading a disciplined army, MR has yet to prove himself as a disciplined President who can bring law and order to a country, where majority of the people are living in fear of a corrupt police force and an intimidating underworld supported by politicians.
Unless MR takes drastic measures to give a free hand to the judiciary and the courts to bring the thugs and murderers, who are operating behind powerful politicians, to justice, most intelligent Sri Lankans will turn to anybody who can assure them of the freedom to live without fear and harassment.
On the other hand if SF is a true patriotic who truly cares about his country and is genuine about bringing law and order to our nation, he should not form any alliance with any opposition party but stand as an independent candidate.
Indi

]]>
By: jansee https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10930 Wed, 18 Nov 2009 14:55:45 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10930 NP:

Yes, you are absolutely right on both of them. That is the irony of it all – whereas they stood on the same side once to display the raw chauvinism and hypocrisy, now they stand opposite each other with “blazing guns” pointed at each other. Imagine the worry and restlessness of the Rajapaksa brothers, particularly Gotabay, when Fonseka was in the US.

I would go as far as saying that MR, for the first time since he pursued the war option, stands to lose the presidency. The moment the war was over, he should have moved fast to resettle the IDPs, instead of giving lame excuses, offer the Tamils a reasonable space that would have accelerated the pace of FDIs into the country. He will live to regret his failure to capitalise on ending the war successfully. If SF does jump into the foray, the deciding votes could be most probably the minorities, particularly the Tamils. In the same way he enticed the LTTE not to partake in the elections, which incidentally paved the way for his election, he is now seeking the favours of the TNA, but I doubt most Tamils up North would want to have anything to do with him, even if it means to throw the support to SF.

What an irony indeed!!

]]>
By: Groundviews https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10883 Tue, 17 Nov 2009 08:26:26 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10883 Suhith, we believe the letter was sent in English.

]]>
By: NP https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10879 Tue, 17 Nov 2009 05:38:26 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10879 Why the assumption, including on the part of the public, that political power is the natural prerogative of the ‘war-hero’?? There’s no difference between MR and SF ideologically and politically: they’re both chauvinists paying lip-service to democratic and humanitarian values.

]]>
By: jansee https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10835 Sun, 15 Nov 2009 13:09:41 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10835 Suhith:

The official letter sent to the President is in English.

Comments:

It was not soon, but IMMEDIATELY after the war with the LTTE was over, the NSA of India flew over to SL. Speculations were rife then that it was about the IDPs and the Tamils question but the main agenda was Sarath Fonseka (SF).

A cardinal principle for a professional in army outfit is to refrain from politics. SF very often crossed this boundary. His infamous interview with the Canadian newsmedia and his comments on a number of politicians and politicsl lacked the discipline of an army officer of his standing. Then again, he has also been shooting through his mouth, like that when he talked about shooting dead LTTEs that surrendered waving white flags. It is not that the Rajapaksa (RP) regime was not blameworthy – not only it nurtured the “out-of-context” general to proscribe the war, it also savoured the military adventure and also made a very dangerous move by dispensing the lines drawn between such military adventures and politics. In fact, all recent elections were won through this blatant propagation. You can’t have it both ways.

There were widespread concerns – why would a general announce that he would like to recruit more soldiers after the war? It had, as it now appears, created panic with the phobia-stricken RP regime. While the general’s logic may lie on the premise that more soldiers would be needed to protect and safeguard than when waging a war, many had sounded the alarm at the general’s comments. He boasted of the military strength of SL. Some even thought that he was indicating indirectly to India not to “mess” around, not realising that it will take India only days to bomb to pulp SL. What is happening in SL will always feature in India’s radar forever and has been openly admitted by MR, SL fought India’s war with the LTTE.

For a general who had not minced his words about the minorities, in a negative way, talking of the welfare of the IDPs and concerns of the rights of the Tamils now has got to do with politics.

Now that SF has decided to discard the uniform, my take is that the impending match between SF and MR is a good one – one that bodes well for democracy. With no others of the stature of SF to take on the President who is riding high after the war, it would be good though that they slug it out. The eerie similarity of his (MR) first election scenario seems to be playing out – the split among the Sinhala votes, the denial of the Tamil votes are all too uncannily similar. Of course, MR is poised to win but not as smoothly and not with the “riding-high” position he had envisaged. He will, in fact, be badly bruised with his ego dented and perhaps learn a lesson that in a country like SL second chances are hard to come by as Ranil Wickramasinghe had painfully found out.

]]>
By: Uthungan https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10833 Sun, 15 Nov 2009 10:25:12 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10833 Kusal has done a splendid piece of exposition of the intents and motives of SF and those ganging up behind him..Hope Mano Ganeshan and others will take heed of all those points and not delude themselves into into aligning with the UNP in the believe that SF would abolish the Executive Presidency and after that milk and honey would flow in Lanka.. On the contrary he would if elected stick on like a limpet to that post and that would evoke serious consequences for the South Asian region. Already the island is on a slippery slope to becoming another Mayanmar and supporting the former CDS would only hasten that process if he becomes President.

]]>
By: srilanken2009 https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10829 Sun, 15 Nov 2009 09:05:13 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10829 Suhith:

it was in English as far as srilanken news papers revealed it all these days.

Roger Francis:

Yes, MR was correct in that regard. I would never think that masses in sl may ever want a millitary leader to govern the country. Many of us dont wish lanka to be called little Pakistan in the near future. What kinds of political background has SF gained to become the head of state for a country that has democratic ruling mechanisms for sucha long time. Perhaps people could easily get manipulated by UNP leader who is now trying to make use of the situation. No doubt, SF deserves the highest respect in terms of elemination of LTTE terrorism within SL but, never forget, under the political leadership of M + SLGO. And also agree with that SF has been the great AC in the lanken defence system. He sacrificed his life for such a long time. But many in sl would not like srilanka to become Pakistan another african state for the region. How can he ever feel to work for the nation as a politial leader, if he is in the opinion – this country for only sinhalese ? I am also a sinhalese, not a MR sympathiser but a srilanken lover while being away from sl for ages.

]]>
By: Whacko https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10826 Sun, 15 Nov 2009 07:40:49 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10826 Its a crazy situation. and if i may be as bold as to speculate, this has a lot to do with our foreign policy and who has the most to gain with the UNP coming into power. The US has lost its leeway and China has made major inroads. It is taken for granted internationally that Hambanthota is really a Chinese naval base, part of the Chinese ‘string of pearls’ strategy to strengthen its military presence for ‘logistical reasons’ in the region.

Getting the UNP to field General SF is a tactic to get someone friendlier to the West into the seat. He is the basic caricature the president in terms of his nationalistic view, so the hardline and not so hardline (but unvariable) supporters of the same wave of national pride will not be deterred at the elections.

We’re fooling ourselves if we actually think that the general is going to abolish the executive presidency if he comes into power. Or he might, and install some new form of militarily oriented rule; using his power in the army. The UNP is also basically selling its soul here. if it ever had one that is. Instead of competing mainly on economic lines as a capitalist party as they usually do they are diluting their brand promise by going on this desperate power grab. Ranil must step down. and the UNP must get their ducks in a row and some sense into their heads. ‘Playing with fire’ may be right; we may be heading for chaos without even knowing it.

]]>
By: Marikar https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10822 Sun, 15 Nov 2009 04:32:54 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10822 President Mahinda Rajapakse should call general elections first. Leave General Fonseka to know his popularity in a District and create manape problems in the Alliance – to know political difficulties and risks. He would be elected to Parliament, an ordinary MP with little security. He would also then realise the dificulties of electioneering – a far cry from the command of non democratic traditions ( as should be) in the Army. Mahinda Rajapakse would still be President and he would be bought over from the other side, given an inconsequential Ministership and all his valour and past would be forgotten. Only so much for his valour? He is blind in politics – so where is the vision? The General would then leave for the USA and all will be forgotten in sad retirement. The JVP would be an also ran at the general election. If the JVP joins the UNAlliance -no worthy Sinhalese would vote for them. This would all augur well for Sri Lanka. We would prosper.

]]>
By: Suhith https://groundviews.org/2009/11/14/the-unwritten-revelations-of-sarath-fonsekas-letter-requesting-retirement-from-service/#comment-10818 Sun, 15 Nov 2009 01:36:44 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/?p=1996#comment-10818 Does anyone know what language was the official letter of resignation written?
PS:
I am very appreciative of this blog. A big Thank you do the blog administrators.

]]>