Comments on: The General and his necessary evils https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=the-general-and-his-necessary-evils Journalism for Citizens Wed, 06 Feb 2008 11:24:02 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.4.1 By: groundviews https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1246 Wed, 06 Feb 2008 11:24:02 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1246 Dear Freddy,

Thanks for writing in and the measure of support. Perhaps this was prompted by the recent IPS story on new media in Sri Lanka, which I’ve responded to in detail here.

You say Groundviews is not citizen journalism. I believe it is.

I believe Groundviews, Vikalpa and Vikalpa Video have raised awareness on how web media in general, and blogs and short online video in particular – in English, Sinhala and Tamil – can promote ideas that critique what’s in mainstream / traditional media in Sri Lanka. The guidelines you are ignorant of that this site operate on can be found here.

I believe that by publishing articles from non-journalists, from IDPs, from relief workers, from civil society activists and creating in the case of Groundviews an award winning site for stories on war, peace and democracy in Sri Lanka, we’ve created something that simply didn’t exist before. And the increasingly numbers coming here seem to suggest that what’s written by ordinary citizens is seen as valuable by many others located in Sri Lanka and abroad.

Meepura I first heard about it years ago when I was working with Sunanda as a small newspaper struggling to make an impact against the traditional media’s stranglehold on the public imagination. Your web presence, which I take is new, is interesting in that it promotes stories from Negombo for what I believe is an audience primarily from Negombo. That’s what may be called hyper-local in citizen journalism. Our effort is different.

There’s room for more than one definition and example of citizen media in Sri Lanka. For our part, we are happy to see Groundviews, and more importantly, Vikalpa and Vikalpa Video champion and demonstrate by example how web based media can evolve into something that gives traditional media a run for their money. It’s desperately needed, given the atrocious quality of journalism we read in both Private and State media for reasons both linked to the despicable nature of the regime today and also the equally damning lack of professionalism in mainstream journalism itself.

Groundviews, VOR Radio, Vikalpa and Vikalpa Video offers perspectives in English, Sinhala, Tamil, audio and video, every day, all week. Our websites as they stand today are a vital record of thoughts that CANNOT be found in traditional journalism. For students of conflict resolution, they are a treasure trove of information. For students on critical discourse during war, they are a living experiment of how the imperfect science of moderation grapples daily with hate speech and how civility is often lost in debates on ethnic identity, religion and the causes of war.

This to me is citizen journalism – it’s real, it’s compelling, it offers no single truth, and for me, exciting to be part of a larger effort that is shaping Sri Lanka’s news and information agenda especially at a time when so much of it is so very one-sided (see here).

I wish you the best in your work and hope you’ll be able to replicate what we have done with our sites in your own footprint of influence.

Best,

Sanjana

P.S. Your website in English, by the way, hasn’t been updated in over a year and the version in Sinhala requires a proprietary font. Both of these kill interest and suggest a venture on to the web that hasn’t been thought through carefully, isn’t well designed, is without compelling content and without anyone within your newspaper with the wherewithal to take forward. This is a pity – the greatest mistake one can make on the web is to do something just because someone else is doing it without thinking about what added value, or difference, one can make.

]]>
By: freddy Gamage https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1245 Wed, 06 Feb 2008 02:51:43 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1245 නුවෙන් ඔබගන්නා උත්සාහය අගේ කරමු. එහෙත් ඔබ විසින් ලේබල් ගසා ඇති පරිදි මේ වෙඩ් අඩවිය පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍ය වෙබ් අඩවියක් ලෙසින් අපි නොදකිමු.+ ඒ අප දන්නා පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍යවෙිදයේ මුලික සංකල්ප වලට අනුවය. ප්‍රධාන ධාරවේ අතිබුහතරයකගේ ලිපි පළකරමින් එය පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍යවේදි අඩවියක් ලෙසින් නම් කිරිමට ඉක්ිමන් ‍නොවන්න. අප දැනට වසර 6 ක් තිස්සේ ඒකි සංකල්ප වෙනුවෙන් නිරන්තර වැඩකොටසක නිරතව සිටිමු. එහෙත් අප තවමත් අප පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍යවේදයක් ගොඩනගා ඇතැයි කියන්නට ඉක්මන් නොවෙමු. අප ඒ වෙනුවෙන් යම් කොටසක් කර ඇත. එහෙන් ඇත්ත අරුතට යන්නට තව තවත් පොරබැදිය යුතුය . ඔබටද ඒ සදහා ශක්තිය පතමු. අපි මීපුර ප්‍රාදේශීය පුවත්පත නො.200 ශා.ජෝශප් විදිය මීගමුව 031-2235089 email-meepura2007.gmail.com]]> පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍යවේදයක් ගොඩනැගිම වෙනුවෙන් ඔබගන්නා උත්සාහය අගේ කරමු.
එහෙත් ඔබ විසින් ලේබල් ගසා ඇති පරිදි මේ වෙඩ් අඩවිය පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍ය වෙබ් අඩවියක් ලෙසින් අපි නොදකිමු.+
ඒ අප දන්නා පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍යවෙිදයේ මුලික සංකල්ප වලට අනුවය.
ප්‍රධාන ධාරවේ අතිබුහතරයකගේ ලිපි පළකරමින් එය පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍යවේදි අඩවියක් ලෙසින් නම් කිරිමට ඉක්ිමන් ‍නොවන්න.
අප දැනට වසර 6 ක් තිස්සේ ඒකි සංකල්ප වෙනුවෙන් නිරන්තර වැඩකොටසක නිරතව සිටිමු.
එහෙත් අප තවමත් අප පුරවැසි ජනමාධ්‍යවේදයක් ගොඩනගා ඇතැයි කියන්නට ඉක්මන් නොවෙමු.
අප ඒ වෙනුවෙන් යම් කොටසක් කර ඇත.
එහෙන් ඇත්ත අරුතට යන්නට තව තවත් පොරබැදිය යුතුය .
ඔබටද ඒ සදහා ශක්තිය පතමු.

අපි

මීපුර ප්‍රාදේශීය පුවත්පත
නො.200
ශා.ජෝශප් විදිය
මීගමුව
031-2235089
email-meepura2007.gmail.com

]]>
By: N https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1244 Tue, 05 Feb 2008 23:41:53 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1244 “Naturally the Tamils should convince the LTTE to stop the war and negotiate, which the LTTE, from all reports, is willing to do.” – eh? which reports are those Robert? Do you have some source of information that the rest of the world is not privy to?

]]>
By: G https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1243 Thu, 27 Dec 2007 09:38:35 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1243 “an overwhelming majority (87%) of the Sinhalese are satisfied with the way the war is waged” -Quote

Is the war the only “relevant” issue for a Sri Lankan democracy? I do not think I have once come across an article outlining the governments economic strategies – do they indeed have one?

]]>
By: sham https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1242 Sun, 23 Dec 2007 06:19:34 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1242 i think what most people who are in colombo cant undersatnd is that common people voted for MR, not due to fact that hes a good leader, or hes a good economist, but becasuse they beliveved that MR would take a military path.

i think their priority lies in a miltary solution before cost of living and anything else…………

just imaging by about three years (next election) SL forces coming close to wanni. then everyone will vote for MR again to finish it. If he has already finished it he will win overwelmingly. so i feel that he is here for full 12 years .

UNP should be looking for sucessors for grooming.
why does anyone try to change peoples believes. majority believe war is the way forward and we should go ahead with that method.

]]>
By: Robert https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1241 Sun, 23 Dec 2007 05:12:25 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1241 Naturally the Tamils should convince the LTTE to stop the war and negotiate, which the LTTE, from all reports, is willing to do.

Above is interesting.

So, tamils are for war from one side. they only want GOSL to stop war and talk to LTTE. In other words, tamils are dishonest.

All these big shoutings about human rights etc., are just for their advantage.

]]>
By: Nagalingam Ethirveerasingam https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1240 Fri, 21 Dec 2007 20:11:31 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1240 s fold), at his Cambridge Terrace Office, that as a political party, UNP will not do anything that will not bring them back to power or if in power put them out of power. Though UNP understood the mind of the Sinhala voters, he took the risk as the Chandrika government flaundered after the Katunayake airport and the Muhamalai debacle. He won. But paid the price when he was not able to trap the LTTE even though UNP Ministers were able to cause the defection of Karuna and his supporters. Rajapakse government is riding high on the shoulders of 70 % or more of the Sinhala voters. He is doing their bidding. Those who want peace in Sri Lanka has to convince at least a mahority of the 70% of Sinhala voters to join the 27.5% of the Sinhala voters who want to stop the war and negotiate with the LTTE. Naturally the Tamils should convince the LTTE to stop the war and negotiate, which the LTTE, from all reports, is willing to do. Just asking Rajapakse to go against the 71.6% is asking him and his party to commit political suicide.]]> To me the war in Sri Lanka seem to be like the Peloponnesian war. So 200 years may be!
Regarding the CPA polls of November 2007 that Pradeep Peris refers to I have an interpretation of the answers by the Sinhala voters (I assume that all were 18 or over.) for first question. “How do you think we can end the war and have peace in Sri Lanka?”

The answers for the options by the Sinhala voters for the above question indicate that the Rajapakse government’s position is in concordance with the majority of Sinhala voters. The war is continued because more than Two-Thirds of Sinhala voters wanted it.

Let us examine the following options that indicate the continuance of military action.
1. Conducting peace talks while having military offensive. (LTTE is not going to Talk while the Military offensive is on. As such the answer is continue the military offensive.)
o Sinhala voters – 13.1 %
2. Political negotiations After Government defeats LTTE.
o Sinhala voters – 10.0 %
3. Government defeating the LTTE
o Sinhala voters – 48.5 %
TOTAL Sinhala voters for Military action – 71.6 %

Even if one leaves out the 13.1 % who want negotiation while prosecuting the war, those who are for a military solution is 58.5 %.

Lalith Athulathmuthali told me on February 4th 1985 at 9:00pm after an independence rally, with priests from the three religions, at the Mount Lavinia Park, that UNP amending the constitution to a federal constitution would be political suicide. He understood the mind of the Sinhala voters and that of the SLFP then.

Ranil Wickremasinghe told me on May 13 (the day the Jeya Sikuru started) at 7:00 PM, in the presence of Mahinda Samarasinghe and Tyrone Fernando (Now in the Rajapakse’s fold), at his Cambridge Terrace Office, that as a political party, UNP will not do anything that will not bring them back to power or if in power put them out of power. Though UNP understood the mind of the Sinhala voters, he took the risk as the Chandrika government flaundered after the Katunayake airport and the Muhamalai debacle. He won. But paid the price when he was not able to trap the LTTE even though UNP Ministers were able to cause the defection of Karuna and his supporters.

Rajapakse government is riding high on the shoulders of 70 % or more of the Sinhala voters. He is doing their bidding. Those who want peace in Sri Lanka has to convince at least a mahority of the 70% of Sinhala voters to join the 27.5% of the Sinhala voters who want to stop the war and negotiate with the LTTE. Naturally the Tamils should convince the LTTE to stop the war and negotiate, which the LTTE, from all reports, is willing to do. Just asking Rajapakse to go against the 71.6% is asking him and his party to commit political suicide.

]]>
By: suntzu https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1239 Fri, 21 Dec 2007 08:38:56 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1239 thekillromeoproject ….machang not 12 years….seems more like the 100 year war between England and France! (In the good old days there was hand to hand combat, unlike today where bombs can be placed at NOLIMIT in Colombo…and civilians can be Kafir bombed in the Wanni!)

]]>
By: thekillromeoproject https://groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1238 Fri, 21 Dec 2007 07:20:03 +0000 http://www.groundviews.org/2007/12/21/the-general-and-his-necessary-evils/#comment-1238 “There remains, then, for him, only one path- the continuation of a hard lined military offensive.”

Which in turn also means, that if the war ends, the people have no more need for MR.

Seems to me, we’re in for a very long war, at least 12 more years ya?

]]>