Colombo, Peace and Conflict

Who gains by war in Sri Lanka?

By Kumar Rupesinghe

Normally it would seem that nobody wants to have war. War is so horrendous and so devastating that nobody in their right minds would want a war. But unfortunately, this is not the case. There are those who benefit from war and make enormous amounts of money. They are called the Merchants of Death.

Today, we will look at the Merchants of Death. These are companies and individuals who profit from war. They are very powerful in the world arena. There are large corporations and companies which focus on the manufacture of arms. These range from the Kalashnikovs to lethal weapons which can harm many. The range of weapons produced by the manufacturers is getting deadlier and more effective. Some of the weapons are built to hurt large numbers of people. There are numerous actors – arms manufacturers, dealers, brokers, financiers and traffickers – who stand to gain through the promotion of war. Amongst them, the so called ‘Merchants of Death’ are of foremost importance. These are arms dealers who make exorbitant sums of money through the legal and illegal manufacture and sale of weapons, mainly small arms. These merchants of death often sell arms to both sides in a conflict.

Who gains by war – the global picture
Some of the largest arms manufacturers are Lockheed-Martin, closely followed by Boeing and Raytheon. The War Resisters League‘s Anti Militarism Coordinator Simon Harak has noted that ‘these companies and corporations are literally calling the shots of the US government’s war making policies. It is not so much that they are making profits from war—their power and influence are so great that it is more accurate to say that they are making war for profit’. What all these companies have in common is that they fund election campaigns and influence the direction of American policy. As you can imagine, the American war in Iraq and Afghanistan have created huge profits for American arms dealers. Apart from the USA, there are many other countries who manufacture weapons, such the U.K, Russia, Czechoslovakia and India, to name only a few.

Annual world military spending today has gone beyond a $1000 billion. At present, it is reported that there are over 500 million small arms in circulation around the world. It was the weapon of choice in 46 out of 49 major conflicts, most of which have been armed insurgencies and intrastate conflicts. In fact, the extent to which human security is threatened by the diffusion of small arms in South Asia is still under appreciated. In addition to the substantial number of casualties, the costs to the families afflicted by this violence are immeasurable. But to most arms dealers, the profit accumulated far outweighs the human costs.

The Sri Lankan scenario
Let us now look at the situation in Sri Lanka. According to Mugabe, a researcher for the Small Arms Survey, there is an estimated fifty two thousand deserters from the Sri Lankan Army and many thousands from the LTTE who have either acquired weapons after deserting or left their posts with their firearms. The survey estimates that there are approximately 300,000 illegal weapons owned by civilians. It is no wonder that the crime rate in Sri Lanka is so high and contract killings have grown astronomically.

Sri Lanka is the most militarised state in South Asia. Sri Lanka’s defence expenditure as a percentage of its GDP is the largest not only in the South Asian region, but overall in the world. Reports indicate that defence expenditure has gone up to Rs. 100 billion a year and is set to increase further, given the new dimension the war has taken in the recent weeks. In the last decade, Sri Lanka has spent almost Rs. 400 billion on defence as a result of the conflict.

At the same time however, the expenditure for education for the year 2005 was a mere Rs. 26 billion, whilst for the same year for the entire health service it was Rs. 30 billion. Just imagine if the money spent on arms purchases was diverted to health and education. Whilst Sri Lanka boasts that 90% of its population is literate, a deeper analysis shows that a majority of our children do not have access to good schools, school text books and sufficient numbers of qualified teachers. It is the same for health services. Our hospitals are over crowded and citizens suffer enormously in obtaining proper health services. Often pregnant mothers have to wait in line to be admitted. There is a shortage of hospital beds for patients. Still, it is the very same citizens, who bear the cost of these arms purchases. The figures given below give a very graphic picture of the staggering increase in military expenditure in Sri Lanka for the period 1983 – 2007.

Budget

Military Expenditure

What is significant is that defence expenditure has almost doubled for this year. If we extrapolate the figures, given the current debate on the need for air defence, then it would be likely that the figure for next year would double again to about Rs. 300 billion . This is obviously untenable and will take the country into bankruptcy. We have to view the escalation in the context of the rising cost of living, the depreciation of the rupee, inflation and the drop in tourist traffic and the low level of foreign direct investment in the country.

The procurement of arms
The procurement of arms is not generally known to the people of the country. According to newspaper reports, weapons merchants and their representatives have been regular visitors to Colombo recently, marketing various forms of equipment deemed necessary to track and destroy enemy aircraft including MiG 29 combat aircraft, which are known to be able to carry air – to -surface missiles as well as TV and laser guided bombs. The average price of a MiG 29 is said to be US $ 15 million [Rs. 1665 million]. According to Iqbal Athas, in ‘Fight Now and Pay Later ‘ [ Sunday Times, 20th May, 2007] ,the government is now considering leasing these combat aircraft on a 7 – 10 year pre arranged credit basis from Russia at an undisclosed cost, which means it will be a successive government that would need to meet the payment for this procurement. It has also been pointed out that the acquisition of these aircraft alone would not mean the SLAF will be able to defend the country’s air space. For the MiG 29s to be able to carry out their mission effectively, it would also be necessary to purchase radar guided, heat seeking infra red or laser guided missiles, the approximate cost of which is US $30,000 apiece. In addition, the Air Force is also planning to acquire a new MiG 29 UB trainer , a spares package, a UAV system, brand new helicopters , overhaul and upgrade existing helicopters , the total cost of which is estimated at a staggering US $ 145 million [ Rs. 16,095,000 million]. Thus, it seems to be a very expensive business to destroy the fledgling Tiger Air Force [ TAF] .Interestingly, it has been likened to buying a brand new Mercedes Benz to knock down a bullock cart, with the question being raised as to whether all these exorbitantly priced and highly sophisticated equipment are really necessary to attack the small Czech built Zlin Z-143 aircraft that the LTTE is said to have in its possession?

A review of international experiences in Israel and Iraq are instructive. For example, the Israeli Government is one of the most sophisticated military powers with sophisticated intelligence, air capacity and a well trained military capacity but they have not been able to deal with the Hezbollah in the Lebanon or quell the Palestinian uprising. A more recent example is the military debacle which the USA is currently facing. During the initial invasion of Iraq , the US military boasted that the war in Iraq would be short and swift and would end in a year and also affect a transfer of power to a National Council. After several years it is now clear the death toll faced by Allied soldiers has become intolerable and that the citizens are suffering enormously with daily suicide bomb attacks killing over 50.

Information on the LTTE military expenditure is not available. However, a recent report on the Cost of Conflict has calculated that its annual income is around $250 – 300 million a year. Part of this money is spent on its cadres and in development work, but the bulk of the money goes into arms purchases. Another report by Human Rights Watch published in the USA indicates that apart from its regular collections, the LTTE recently called for a collection of taxes from the Diaspora for the ‘Final War’. It collected $3000 from each family, over $10,000 from business houses and $100,000 from Hindu temples. In a calculation I made based on these figures it would seem that the LTTE collected a staggering amount which could be over Rs. 100 billion. Apart from the collection from taxing Tamils abroad and in the country, they operate a fleet of shipping vessels, invest in businesses and also engage in drug trafficking. All this allows the LTTE to purchase deadly weapons in the pursuit of its war objectives.
Conclusion

If the war continues it is clear that costs will rise exponentially and this would mean that both the Tamil people and the Sinhalese will be the losers. The war will be waged and the children will be deprived of an education, the people will not have proper public transport and the country as a whole will be trapped in an ever increasing morass of continuous military expenditure. It also means that both the warring parties will try to secure more and more sophisticated weapons until the war engulfs the country in tragedy after tragedy.

The citizens of Sri Lanka have a role to play. They cannot be bystanders, for it is they who pay for the war and it is their children who will have to bear the burden of the massive investment in arms. The citizens must hold both the parties accountable and build a movement which would be an alternative to war.

  • sam

    I am curious if there is any data that would indicate what proportion of the international aid can be allocated to the state’s military expenditure.

    Also, is there any graphs or evidence that plots what the state spends on, say, health or education, over the past 15 years?

    Further, is there any indication what countries are supplying Sri Lanka with arms? I understand that China may be prepared to underwrite the Government’s weapons expense account.

    Lastly, I found your analysis of how much funds the LTTE has raised for the so-called ‘final war’ too simplistic. More work needs to be done in this area of how much real support the LTTE has from the diaspora – it’s a very blurry area. It would be useful to know the formula used to come up with the ‘over Rs. 100 billion’ figure.

  • sceptic

    I have a few issues with this piece:
    1. the author never really answers the question (from either side). Who gains from the GOSL side? Who gains from the ltte side? Who are the merchants of death we are supporting? It hardly looks like we deal directly with Boeing, Lockheed-Martin or Rayethon…

    2. the author himself is a direct beneficiary of the war. he is a self-confessed peace-monger and in his own way feeds off wars..case in point sierra leone and what he wants to do in sri lanka

  • If some one was determined enough to finish the war completely ,what ever the cost at the early stages,we wouldn’t have to spend this amount on war now.Lets finish it this time.

  • We have to replace HOSTILITY with HOSPITALITY to initiate the process and encourage all parties to come to the table and create peace rapidly, as it is not only the education of children that has been ruined. The whole country is already degraded with rampant dishonesty, high unemployment/underemployment, low levels of social and moral values and the poor increasing. This is because; we have very few honest, professional, talented, creative and “Active” leaders that can develop efficient programs in every area and domain (Even in the area of resolving conflict and PEACEBUILDING) that need to function efficiently to take our country forward. The discouragement faced by the few honest people (Less than 1% who do what they say), the incapacity of families and communities to interact and think through solutions, the blockage of their willpower and initiatives and also the inability of having access to identify and develop the talents of children, youth and young adults (Who were children at one time) have retarded the development of the minds and skills of everyone. The rumors of intimidations have also killed the spirit and initiative of honest persons. If we continue to not seek solutions, it is all common persons (Including children) in the country that will be affected and we will have a failed state very soon. Why do not our leaders (In the west, south, east, north and central) of Sri Lanka analyze the benefits to be gained (by exploiting the natural resources of Sri Lanka -talents and entrepreneurial power of people for manufacture- high agricultural production (by making it dignified and attractive to youth to engage in the sub-sector through mechanization and incentives such as clean environments and high salaries) – hospitality and attractions to lure tourists and developing products and services for them – Aurveda- Meditation – Wellness and others) if there is total peace. The leaders may even win the Nobel Prize for peace. War will only ruin Sri Lanka and all children of ALL ethnic groups and religious affiliations (Except the few who can go abroad). Let us UNITE and analyze the advantages of POP (Power of Peace) over the POW (Power of War) and eradicate everything that is preventing us from becoming a great and prosperous nation. Let us collect totally Honest, Non-Violent, and Neutral (Without religious, political, ethnic, fame, family or affluence affiliations) persons and set up “Active” concerned citizens (CC) groups in every community in Sri Lanka, analyze the challenges and options, reflect on solutions and put forward our recommendations (Professionally and in an unbiased manner) to the leaders to move forward rapidly. If not, we may see the Arrival of DOOMSDAY soon. We cannot expect peace to arrive if we “passively” express it at gatherings, places of worship, prayers or at manifestations and later go home and watch television images of ourselves manifesting, have a good meal, protect our families and go to sleep. Very few honest, peace loving and neutral citizens (Who do not have underlying agendas) would also like to be seen or heard at demonstrations and manifestations. So we should not expect peace to come automatically, and intimidating current leaders will only delay the process. For more information on how selected communities in conflict were enticed to resolve issues and move forward in Africa: http://www.tidycentre.com – Sunimal Alles – [email protected] Tel: 00-94-112763539 We can do it if we wished! Let us wake up and act before it is too late.